Amvls@hotmail.com
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the relationship between physical and psychological family violence against adolescents and dissatisfaction with body image.
METHODS: This study assessed dissatisfaction with body image using the Body Area Scale ; psychological violence against adolescents using the Psychological Violence Scale against Adolescents; and physical violence between parents and adolescents using the Conflict Tactics Scales Form R (CTS-1). A total of 201 adolescents aged 10 to 19 years enrolled in a Family Assistance Program of a Health Center in the city of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, were analyzed. Bivariate and multivariate analyses were performed to estimate associations between family violence (physical and psychological) and dissatisfaction with body image. The associations between the variables were expressed as odds ratios and their respective confidence intervals (95%) estimated via logistic regression.
RESULTS: Psychological violence was associated with body image dissatisfaction only for female adolescents (OR = 4.2; 95% confidence interval, 1.37 to 12.86).
CONCLUSION: These results suggest that it is important to implement education and health policies to inform the public about the harmful effects of psychological violence during adolescence.
Univariate analysis, determining absolute and relative frequencies (prevalence) for categorical variables, and summary measure (mean, median, standard deviation) for numerical variables; Bivariate analysis, considering the body image variable as the outcome. For categorical variables, according to the contingency tables determined for each variable versus outcome, the Chi-square test was selected to test the association between them. For numerical variables, the unpaired Student’s t-test was used; Univariate logistic regression analysis (crude) between the exposure variables (minor physical violence, severe physical violence and psychological violence) and outcome variable (dissatisfaction with body image) and covariates of interest; Multivariate logistic models were created for each exposure variable (minor physical violence, severe physical violence, and psychological violence) and outcome variable (dissatisfaction with body image), adjusted for covariates that presented p < 0.20 in the crude analyses. The criterion of statistical significance for the multivariate logistic model was p < 0.05; The models were diagnosed using the Hosmer-Lemeshow test. The model was considered well adjusted when p > 0.05; and Odds ratios (OR) for each exposure variable in the multivariate logistic models, in addition to the respective 95% confidence intervals and p value.To perform the analysis, the study used Epi Info 2000 to create the database, the software R Studio version 0.96.0331, and the R version 2.15 with MKmisc and epicalc packages and extensions for a more in-depth analysis. Only adolescents and their legal guardians who agreed and signed the Free and Informed Consent Form were included in the research. The research was approved and authorized by the Research Ethics Committee of the Municipal Health Department of Rio de Janeiro (opinion no. 122A/2007). RESULTS Table 1 shows the demographic and personal information of the adolescents studied. Regarding body image, approximately 20% of the adolescents were dissatisfied. Female adolescents had higher values of dissatisfaction with body image than male adolescents, but this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.454). Table 2 shows the frequency of each type of family violence perpetrated by parents against adolescents. Almost half of the sample experienced psychological violence, but female adolescents were the main victims. With regard to other types of violence, 30% of both sexes suffered serious physical violence and approximately 40% suffered minor physical violence. Based on the results obtained from the bivariate analysis (Table 3), it was observed that, for male adolescents, their nutritional status was significantly associated with body image (p = 0.018). Those who were overweight were 4 times more likely to be dissatisfied with their body image. For female adolescents, in addition to nutritional status (p = 0.019), psychological violence (p = 0.015) and housing conditions (p = 0.041) were also significantly associated with dissatisfaction with body image, that is, overweight, the presence of psychological violence and inadequate housing conditions generate approximately 3 times more chances of dissatisfaction with body image. The information from the multivariate models in relation to the OR and their respective confidence intervals are shown in Table 4. The models used the explanatory variables (types of violence), nutritional status and age for male adolescents and for female adolescents the types of violence, nutritional status and housing conditions. Para os adolescentes do sexo masculino (Tabela 4), as análises mostraram que nenhum tipo de violência foi significativamente associado à insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal (violência física menor – p = 0,668; violência física grave – p = 0,670 e violência psicológica – p = 0,854). Para as adolescentes do sexo feminino (Tabela 4), apenas a violência psicológica esteve significativamente associada à insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal (p = 0,012). Assim, as adolescentes do sexo feminino que sofreram violência psicológica tiveram 4,2 vezes mais chances de estarem insatisfeitas com a imagem corporal do que aqueles que nao sofreram violência psicológica. Apesar de nao serem estatisticamente significativas, as associaçoes foram positivas entre a violência física e a insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal das adolescentes (violência física menor – p = 0,242 e violência física grave – p = 0,076). Quanto mais grave a violência física, maior é a insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal – violência física menor (OR=1,8; IC=0,67-4,80) e violência física grave (OR=2,5; IC=0,91-7,01). O diagnóstico do modelo logístico multivariado mostrou, em ambos os sexos, valor de p superior a 0,05 para todos os tipos de violência familiar (dados nao mostrados). DISCUSSAO Este estudo investigou a relaçao entre a violência familiar realizada pelos pais e a insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal dos adolescentes monitorados pelo Programa de Assistência à Família. Era esperado que o adolescente vítima de violência apresentasse maior insatisfaçao com sua imagem corporal. Essa hipótese foi suportada somente para as adolescentes do sexo feminino vítimas de violência psicológica, tanto em análises bivariadas quanto multivariadas. A exposiçao a fatores estressantes nos estágios iniciais da vida pode afetar a imagem corporal. Murray, Byrne e Rieger19, em seu estudo envolvendo 533 adolescentes australianos, examinaram a relaçao entre estresse e imagem corporal e descobriram que as adolescentes do sexo feminino com maiores níveis de estresse apresentaram mais sintomas de depressao, maior insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal e baixa autoestima do que os adolescentes do sexo masculino. Quando se considera que a existência de violência familiar pode ser uma situaçao estressante para os adolescentes20, a imagem corporal é consequentemente afetada de forma negativa, o que leva aos mesmos resultados do presente estudo. Desta forma, as adolescentes do sexo feminino expostos à violência mostram maior insatisfaçao com a imagem corporal. Em relaçao aos tipos de violência, os estudos que investigaram a relaçao entre violência e imagem corporal em adolescentes avaliaram a violência sexual21-23, a violência física21, 23 e a negligência22. Schaaf e McCanne23, researching female students, found no relationship between physical and sexual violence and body image distortions, despite the fact that young females who suffered physical abuse had higher personal expectations and greater difficulty in identifying emotions and sensations of hunger and satiety. However, Logio 21 , when evaluating 1571 adolescents in New Castle (USA), observed that those who suffered physical and sexual violence showed changes in the perception of their body image towards excess weight, with greater evidence for female adolescents. At the same time, there was a strong correlation between adolescents with a history of abuse and the presence of eating disorders and dieting behavior. Ramalhete and Santos 22 , in a study with female adolescents who were victims of neglect and sexual abuse, observed that these adolescents had a more negative view of the body, regardless of the type of violence. These findings identify past experiences of abuse as a risk factor for unhealthy eating practices and an unhealthy self-assessment of body image. It is important to emphasize that there are few studies on the subject 5,21,22 and these employ different methodologies to assess body image and measure family violence. Regarding body image, instruments/scales can assess body image disturbances according to perceptual and attitudinal aspects. Studies that express the perceptual component measure body image by the degree of accuracy with which body size is perceived, while the attitudinal component expresses the affective and cognitive components 24 . Most of the studies mentioned above measured body image according to the attitudinal aspect, despite the use of different scales/instruments. It is worth mentioning that this study also assessed body image by the attitudinal aspect. In family violence, there is disagreement among researchers regarding the definition of which types of behaviors or punishments should be considered abuse and also regarding temporality – past versus current 25 . Consequently, it is not always possible to compare the results found in the few existing investigations. Yet, evidence suggests that a stressful family environment creates serious problems in the development of children and adolescents 26 . Despite the relative lack of studies examining the relationship between psychological violence and body image dissatisfaction in adolescents, existing research shows a link between violence in childhood and body image problems in adulthood 26. Violence suffered in childhood has negative consequences and can lead to the emergence of psychopathologies in adulthood. Psychological violence has been associated with self-criticism, dissatisfaction with body image, depression and low self-esteem among adults 5 . Therefore, it is important to have a safe and supportive family environment to develop a healthy body image in individuals, particularly in the case of adolescents. The body is not simply a biological machine, but a body that comprises a history of relational experiences that will assist in the development of the individual and in the ability to deal with stressful situations. It is also a means of regulating affections or resolving problems of a relational/personal nature 27 . Eubanks et al. 4 , in their study with 38 university students, observed that victims of physical and psychological abuse felt that their parents loved them less, gave them less support and acted as a negative role model in their lives. This shows once again how the existence of physical or psychological violence within the family can negatively affect the lives of the individuals involved. From this perspective, healthy relationships that adolescents enjoy with other family members are potentially decisive in leading to adequate development and good social relationships 27 . This study has certain limitations: the first concerns the sample design, which was based on a cross-sectional study, which is not capable of inferring the temporality of the associations described. The second limitation refers to the type of sample. The present study used a convenience sample of individuals registered in the Family Assistance Program, with similar socioeconomic characteristics. Another limitation to be considered refers to the variables that may be involved in the relationship between violence and dissatisfaction with body image, which were not addressed here and which can generate body image problems, such as: shame, self-criticism, mood swings, perfectionism, puberty, self-objectification, identification of gender roles, sexuality, anxiety and other experiences that are potential mediators in the relationship between childhood maltreatment and body image problems. 5. Furthermore, given that some children who suffer abuse do not develop serious psychological consequences or other health problems, it is an important task for the future to identify the factors that protect these children from the negative consequences of abuse. From this point of view, it is important that further research investigate the relationship between family violence and body image, developing longitudinal studies and considering other aspects, such as compensatory mechanisms, psychological factors and the perception of family relationships that, when favorable, help in overcoming trauma. CONCLUSION Despite the limitations, this was the first study on the relationship between physical and psychological violence and body image dissatisfaction in Brazilian adolescents. Based on the results of this study, it can be assumed that psychological violence is linked to body image dissatisfaction in female adolescents. This knowledge can help to support strategies that allow adolescents and their parents to understand the detrimental effects that an unfavorable family environment can have on an adolescent’s growth and development. It should also be clear to society that violence, culturally accepted as part of the educational process, can have negative consequences for the formation of body image.
Rua da Conceição, 100, Centro, Niterói, RJ, Postal Code: 24020-085, Brazil.
revista@adolescenciaesaude.com