Beyond Attendance: Assessing The Performance of Local Legislators in Polewali Mandar, Indonesia, 2019–2024
Keywords:
Legislative Performance; Local Parliament; Performance Accountability; Legislative Independence; Work Commitment.Abstract
Local legislatures in decentralised Indonesia are expected to translate citizens' aspirations into regional regulations, budgets, and effective oversight of the executive, yet their performance is rarely examined beyond attendance and the number of meetings held. This study analyses the performance of members of the Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) of Polewali Mandar Regency, West Sulawesi, during the 2019–2024 term. A descriptive qualitative design was applied through in-depth interviews with DPRD members, including commission leaders, observation of legislative activities at the DPRD Secretariat, and analysis of planning documents, organisational structures, and the 2024 performance accountability evaluation. Performance was examined through six dimensions: quality, quantity, timeliness, effectiveness, independence, and work commitment. The findings show that the formal quality of institutional performance reached a score of 69.15, or grade B, but remained weak in performance measurement and reporting. Quantitative output was sustained by a dense structure of commissions and bodies, yet activity volume was not matched by measurable legislative results. Timeliness was secured for mandatory budget deadlines but not consistently for regulation drafting and follow-up of aspirations. Effectiveness was limited because aspirations were absorbed more successfully than they were converted into policy. Independence was constrained by fragmented party factions, executive-drafted proposals, and limited expert support, while work commitment varied considerably between members. The performance of the DPRD therefore rests more on institutional routines than on individual accountability for results. Individual performance reporting, a legislative timeliness calendar, structured public consultation, and stronger expert support are required to improve legislative performance.

