Reinforced Motivation in The Face of Media Pressure on Pretrial Detention, Jurisprudential Contrast Between Peru and Ecuador

Authors

  • Rosita del Pilar Fernández Armas
  • Cecilia Vela Rengifo
  • Rubén Santisteban Seclén

Keywords:

parallel trials, pretrial detention, presumption of innocence, judicial reasoning, comparative law.

Abstract

The study aimed to determine how parallel trials influence due process within pretrial detention, based on a contrast between Peruvian and Ecuadorian case law. It was basic research with a qualitative approach and a grounded theory design, whose only technique was documentary analysis, applied through a record sheet to ten rulings, five from Peru and five from Ecuador, interpreted with a hermeneutic method. The findings showed that both systems demand individualized reasoning that does not rest on the gravity or notoriety of the case, and that this demand works as the only verifiable indicator of judicial neutrality against media pressure. It was also observed that Peru corrects afterwards, through habeas corpus, whereas Ecuador intervenes in advance, by requiring prosecutors to justify why alternative measures are insufficient and by preventing pretrial detention from approaching the length of the sentence. It was determined that parallel trials endanger the impartiality of the judge and the presumption of innocence, although neither legal system yet has binding criteria that expressly acknowledge that influence.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-16

How to Cite

Fernández Armas, R. del P., Rengifo, C. V., & Seclén, R. S. (2026). Reinforced Motivation in The Face of Media Pressure on Pretrial Detention, Jurisprudential Contrast Between Peru and Ecuador. Adolescência E Saúde, 555–561. Retrieved from https://adolescenciaesaude.com/index.php/aes/article/view/3342

Issue

Section

Original Articles