Incidental Thyroid Carcinoma in Patients Undergoing Surgery for Presumed Benign Multinodular Goitre: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Authors

  • Mousa Basim Mousa Alqadan
  • Reef Haroun Ahmad Al-Qaisi
  • Amro Ra'ed AbdAljaleel AlMbidin
  • Abdallah Daradkeh
  • Rama J. Alawneh
  • Abeer A. Alsarairah

Keywords:

Multinodular goitre; incidental thyroid carcinoma; thyroidectomy; papillary thyroid microcarcinoma; systematic review; meta-analysis

Abstract

Background: Incidental thyroid carcinoma is sometimes identified after surgery for presumed benign multinodular goitre (MNG). Reported detection proportions vary widely, limiting their use in preoperative counselling. This review estimated the postoperative carcinoma proportion and examined its histology and sources of variation. Methods: PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science were searched for peer-reviewed studies published from 12 November 2011 to 12 November 2026. Two independent authors assessed full texts and extracted eligible study data. Patient-level carcinoma counts from MNG-specific surgical cohorts were synthesized using a random-effects meta-analysis of logit-transformed proportions. Heterogeneity, restricted-subgroup estimates, leave-one-out influence and exploratory clinicopathological associations were examined. Results: Of 2,233 retrieved records, 1,454 duplicates and 622 title/abstract records were removed. Of 157 full-text reports reviewed, 146 were excluded because eligibility criteria were unmet and/or extractable quantitative data were insufficient. Eleven cohorts (7,400 surgical patients; 1,449 incidental carcinomas) were included. The pooled postoperative carcinoma proportion was 13.7% (95% confidence interval [CI], 7.9%–22.7%), with substantial heterogeneity (I² = 98.2%). Excluding toxic-MNG-only cohorts yielded 12.8% (95% CI, 6.8%–22.8%). Papillary carcinoma predominated where histology was reported. In two studies, the pooled crude odds ratio for male versus female sex was 1.27 (95% CI, 1.04–1.56); other risk-factor results were largely study-specific. Conclusions: Incidental carcinoma is a measurable postoperative finding in selected patients undergoing surgery for presumed benign MNG, but differences among cohorts are too large for a single percentage to predict individual risk. Histological subtype, preoperative selection and surgical context should guide interpretation. The findings do not support routine extensive surgery solely on the basis of the pooled proportion.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-16

How to Cite

Alqadan, M. B. M., Al-Qaisi, R. H. A., AlMbidin, A. R. A., Daradkeh, A., Alawneh, R. J., & Alsarairah, A. A. (2026). Incidental Thyroid Carcinoma in Patients Undergoing Surgery for Presumed Benign Multinodular Goitre: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Adolescência E Saúde, 854–867. Retrieved from https://adolescenciaesaude.com/index.php/aes/article/view/3437

Issue

Section

Original Articles