Stigma, Silence, and Structural Barriers to Mental Health Help-Seeking Among Domestic Violence Survivors: A Scoping Review Focusing on Rural and Tribal Communities of Central India, Uttarakhand, and Nepal
Keywords:
domestic violence; intimate partner violence; mental health; help-seeking behaviour; stigma; rural health; tribal population; Uttarakhand; Nepal; scoping review.Abstract
Background: Domestic violence (DV) is a well-established determinant of poor mental health among women, yet survivors in rural and tribal settings of South Asia rarely translate psychological distress into help-seeking. Central India, the hill state of Uttarakhand, and Nepal share overlapping features of patriarchal kinship structures, dispersed hill and forest geographies, weak mental health infrastructure, and pronounced stigma, but the pathways connecting these features to help-seeking behaviour have not been mapped collectively.
Objective: This scoping review synthesises available evidence on the stigma-related, socio-cultural, and structural barriers that shape mental health help-seeking among DV survivors in rural and tribal communities of Central India, Uttarakhand, and Nepal, and situates the findings within an explanatory conceptual framework.
Methods: The review followed the Arksey and O’Malley methodological framework as refined by Levac and colleagues, and is reported according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR). A Population-Concept-Context (PCC) question guided a structured search of PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Web of Science, CINAHL, PsycINFO, and grey-literature sources (WHO, NIMHANS, national demographic and health surveys, and government legislative texts) for records published between 2000 and 2026. Findings were charted and analysed thematically and interpreted using Andersen’s Behavioural Model of Health Services Use and Heise’s ecological framework of violence.
Results: Thirty-two sources met inclusion criteria, comprising population-based surveys, qualitative studies, mixed-methods evaluations, systematic and narrative reviews, and normative/legal documents. Four interlocking themes emerged: (i) a substantial and consistent association between DV exposure and adverse mental health outcomes, with treatment gaps exceeding 80% in national data; (ii) internalised and community-level stigma that frames both DV disclosure and mental illness as shameful, discrediting attributes; (iii) a culturally reinforced silence in which violence is normalised as a private, marital matter, particularly acute in tribal communities marked by alcohol-linked violence and in Himalayan hill communities marked by isolation and workload-related distress; and (iv) structural barriers including the near-absence of trained mental health personnel, poor transport and connectivity in hill and forest terrain, weak implementation of protective legislation, and health systems that are not trauma-informed. Nepal reflected an even lower formal help-seeking rate than India, with informal kin-based disclosure dominating across all three settings.
Conclusion: Stigma, silence, and structural deficits interact synergistically rather than independently to suppress help-seeking among DV survivors in these settings. Community-based, task-shared mental health delivery models, integration of DV screening into primary care and frontline health-worker platforms, culturally tailored anti-stigma communication, and stronger implementation of existing legal protections are required. Future primary research using standardised, comparable instruments across Central India, Uttarakhand, and Nepal is needed to strengthen the currently uneven evidence base, particularly for Scheduled Tribe and hill populations.

